eCommerce Strategy

Shopify Subscriptions App: 5 Must-Know Tips for your Program

Oct 07, 2022   •   5 Min Read

If you’ve found this blog, you likely have product(s) that you currently sell, or wish to sell, with a Shopify subscriptions app. Before we jump in, We all must understand the three most common categories of subscription programs that are used across the internet.

Types of Subscription Programs


The replenishment subscription model is most commonly applied to everyday consumable goods that customers need on a recurring basis. Customers use this offering because of the convenience of items showing up at just the right time. On top of that, these replenishment programs typically include a modest discount on products that would otherwise be bought at full price.

eCommerce Subscriptions ReplenishmentAccording to Recharge’s State of Subscription Commerce Report, it was found that 32% of merchants use a Shopify subscriptions app chose this model. Merchants can leverage this model with anything from food products such as meal kits and coffee to disposable items like deodorant and cleaning supplies. The most well-known example of this program is Amazon’s Subscribe and Save on Prime-shipped items.


This model gives subscribers hand-selected items based on their pre-defined interests. Typically a user will select interests/categories upon signup and will be automatically sent a package every month. The package they receive will surprise them with items related to the interests and categories selected.

Shopify Subscriptions App eCommerce

The added value for customers is that they receive items expert-level curation services of products at a price lower than can be found elsewhere. Family and friends will gift a 12-month subscription to a curation subscription like this for a birthday or special occasion. A fairly well-known example of this subscription type is Bespoke Post. This model works well for home goods products, foods & beverages, and the beauty and wellness vertical.

This is easily the most common subscription program type leveraged as of 2022. Over half of merchants surveyed in Recharge’s State of Subscription Commerce Report choose to offer this model, with the exact figure clocking in at 55%.


The access model is often applied to digital content, software, and communities. Brands charge a recurring monthly fee to users that enables them to interact with a mastermind community, access tutorials, or use software. In some cases. this membership allows users to become part of an exclusive club to receive individualized perks like first access to new launches and limited-time products.

Shopify Subscriptions AccessThis business model is highly successful because once brands make an initial investment to create the digital product, each customer translates to recurring revenue with only a minimal service cost. Common examples of access subscriptions are Adobe’s Creative Suite, Peloton, Crossrope, and Pela.

Optimizing Your Subscription Program

If you are able to advertise and market your subscription offering effectively, you will have new subscribers joining every week. The goal of merchants with existing subscription programs is to increase the CLV (Customer Lifetime Value) for as many subscribers as possible to maximize revenue.

Additional Member Benefits

The difference between a one-month subscriber and a lifetime subscriber is the perceived value they receive in relation to the amount of money spent each month. In a rapidly expanding and developing market such as subscriptions, your offerings need to be constantly evolving.

Subscription Program Audience


Does your subscription program include a members-only forum or live chat feature? These limited hangout groups often foster genuine relationships and high-value conversations because each member is paying to be there. Once a subscriber ingrains themselves into your community, they are often less likely to leave.


Offering gated content to your members is a great way to provide added value. You must ensure that you continuously post on a regular basis, or subscribers will consume all of your content and have no reason to stick around. The content you produce can be simple iPhone vlogs, articles, or opinion pieces. Everything you produce does not need to be a large-scale production but remember - it does need to provide value.

Shopify Gated ContentDiscounts

Offering your subscribers discounts on up-sell products that would otherwise be listed at higher prices is another small but effective way to keep them on the hook and raise their AOV (Average Order Value) every month. Remember, always be providing more perceived value than the cost in dollars that your customers pay.

Loyalty & Rewards Programs

eCommerce Integrations

Finding a loyalty and rewards tool that integrates with not only your eCommerce platform (Shopify) but also your Subscription platform (Recharge) used to be time-consuming and difficult. With an integration such as, these systems can communicate with each other seamlessly.

But why should you add loyalty and rewards to your subscription offering?

Increase Customer Retention

By creating an incentive-based system that provides value to your customers, they are likely to stick around for longer periods of time. Offering loyalty points for activities such as sharing on social media, staying a member for 6 months, or referring a friend (more on that below) will create emotionally invested customers.

The longer a customer stays subscribed, the longer you can operate without needing to spend on advertising to replace them.

Product Bundles

This optimization tip can blur the lines between the curation and replenishment models. Bundling means that a subscriber can choose their own selection of products for a singular monthly price. Product bundling can apply to anything from scented soaps to completed outfits.

Learn more about bundles from our preferred subscription platform, Recharge.

Increase Value To Customers

Offering new ways to purchase products is often all that is needed to push a potential customer over the line. Customers that may have previously been deterred from subscribing because they could not select the products they will be receiving will have their objections resolved.

Liquidate Stale Inventory

You may be able to sell products that have sat in inventory for too long and are at risk of going out of style when offered in bundles. By getting creative with how you offer your products, you can turn more potential revenue into actualized revenue.

Shopify Subscriptions App


Personalization is an increasingly relevant tactic in eCommerce. In a non-subscription setting, personalization means using user data to create a specialized experience for a specific website visitor.

With a Shopify subscriptions app, personalization means encouraging users to provide preferences and feedback after each recurring payment. This feedback should then be processed into the products you are providing them with their next purchase to create a better customer experience. A better customer experience means more value to the customer, which equals a long-time subscriber.


Reduce Customer Acquisition Costs

Creating a referral network is a Shopify subscriptions app hack that too few retailers take advantage of. By getting your current subscribers to sell your subscription plan for you, you will not need to obtain nearly as many new subscribers yourself. When done correctly, referrals can lead to an exponential increase in the number of new paying subscribers you can count on for revenue.

Provide Incentive
Shopify Subscriptions App Handshake

Give both the referring customer and the newly subscribed customer a reason to participate in the referral program. This could be a free month, a free gift, or a major discount. When this method of bringing in new customers is perfected, you may have your most loyal customers creating organic social content online to reap the benefits of your referral program.

Shopify Apps Demystified: Learn Which Ones to Trust

The Shopify App Store is overflowing with choices. Let our team’s blogs enlighten you on which apps truly deliver value.


If you are looking to bring your existing products into a recurring revenue model, or optimize your existing Shopify subscriptions app, we are here to help. With over 15 years of eCommerce experience, our experts will be able to deliver impact-driven results to your business in no time. Reach out to one of our Shopify and eCommerce subscription specialists using the form below.

Explore more tags: eCommerce Strategy Blog
Related Content

You Also May Like


BigCommerce Feedonomics: A Framework for Omnichannel Growth

When selling products across multiple eCommerce platforms, strategic visibility and...
Learn More

15 Shopify Website Examples To Inspire eCommerce Site Design in 2024

At Groove, we work with several eCommerce platforms, and Shopify is one of the most...
Learn More

Use The HubSpot Shopify Integration To Sync Customer Data

Introduction Running an online store is full of day-to-day excitement, but the data...
Learn More

Klaviyo Abandoned Cart: 5 Strategies to Increase Conversion

It takes a lot of work to get customers to your eCommerce store. Whether you use SEO...
Learn More

Omnisend vs Klaviyo: A Marketer's Perspective on the Best Choice

One of the main factors to consider when growing your brand is choosing an email...
Learn More

Klaviyo Email Marketing: 5 Reasons They Stand Out in 2024

In 2024, email marketing is far from dead. Contrary to popular belief, it continues...
Learn More
20 Best Shopify Apps LP Background Small

20 Best Shopify Apps For Your eCommerce Store

Download e-Book

Let's Grow Your eCommerce Business, Together.